Wizer Logo
Solutions
PRICINGTHE WIZER HUB

The Power of Wise Crowds

In the world of decision-making, one concept stands out: the wisdom of crowds. At Wizer, we believe that a wise crowd collectively knows more than the wisest person within it. But what's the secret to harnessing this wisdom, and how does it differ from traditional methods like committees, surveys, and polls?

AUTHOR: Kylee Ingram


In the world of decision-making, one concept stands out: the wisdom of crowds. At Wizer, we believe that a wise crowd collectively knows more than the wisest person within it. But what's the secret to harnessing this wisdom, and how does it differ from traditional methods like committees, surveys, and polls?

How Wisdom Emerges

Wisdom isn't conjured magically; it's the product of shared knowledge. It arises when individuals contribute their insights, bit by bit, creating an aggregate of information. Think of it as a puzzle where everyone holds a piece. Caltech economist Charlie Plott likens it to fishing: imagine being on a boat, searching for fish. Instead of peering into the water, look up, and you might spot several birds circling and diving. Each bird has a fragment of the answer, and together, they form a guiding signpost—much like an "information aggregation mechanism." At Wizer, our platform efficiently brings these puzzle pieces together, facilitating wisdom to emerge.

Fostering Innovation with Trusted Decisions

Competition for resources is inherent in many organisations, but confidence in the fairness of the process is key. Doubt can arise when decision-makers are veiled or processes are opaque. At Wizer, we emphasise trust at every stage. Our decision processes are transparent, and voting is 'reputational,' linking the voter's identity to their vote. This builds confidence and encourages:

  • Participants to contribute their best ideas.

  • Decision-makers to take ownership.

  • Wider community buy-in.

Innovative solutions often arise from a trusted decision process, enabling the risk-taking and buy-in crucial to real innovation.

A Wise Crowd vs. Committees

Committees and wise crowds value expertise but differ significantly in other aspects. While committees prioritise collegiality and selection processes, wise crowds focus on diversity and independence. Expertise in a wise crowd is multidimensional, with overlapping knowledge. Collegiality, on the other hand, is not a requirement, as diversity and independent perspectives are essential. The selection process ensures independence, avoiding groupthink.

In a wise crowd, diversity of opinion, independence, decentralisation, and aggregation are key factors. So, which is better depends on your goal. Choose a committee if you want answers that please the question poser, and opt for a wise crowd if you seek informed, balanced answers more likely to be correct.

Beyond Polls and Surveys: The Wisdom of Crowds

Polls and surveys are widely used for decision-making, but they come with limitations such as cost, populism, and atomism. Wise crowd methods offer an attractive alternative:

  • They are cost-effective and less burdensome.

  • They prioritize the right answer over popularity.

  • They can be social-focused, capturing community preferences.

Wise crowds, composed of as few as 6-7 individuals, excel in aggregating information and providing accurate answers, regardless of popularity or representation. When you need the best answers for a group, community, or population, wise crowd processes offer a distinct advantage over polls and surveys.

Related Blogs

By Kylee Ingram

2 min read

Superforecasters: Balancing Expertise in Decision Making

In the realm of predictions and decision-making, there is a fascinating concept known as "Superforecasters." But what makes a Superforecaster, and how does this concept r...

By David Court

3 min read

Using Wizer to shortlist

Shortlisting is harder than it looks. Say you advertise an amazing job at your organisation and get 300 applications. How do you sort these down to a shortlist?...

By Kylee Ingram

2 min read

Introducing Wizer Expert Leaderboards - Celebrating the Heroes of Knowledge

We believe that connecting with genuine expertise leads to better decisions and meaningful interactions. With our Expert Leaderboards, we aim to highlight the remarkable ...

The Wizerd World

  • Explore
  • Team
  • Contact

The Wizer Hub

    Connect

    Wizer Email Subscription

    Subscribe for latest news & updates.

    © 2023 Wizer


    Terms & Condition


    Privacy